How to audit your SMB clients SEO ranking and AI search visibility

Izzy Fletcher • 7 August 2025

New BrightEdge research shows that ChatGPT and Google are now giving wildly different responses to the same searches, with healthcare hit the hardest (a 62% divergence rate).


So while you're still optimising for Google, your clients' potential customers are getting sent to your competitors via ChatGPT.



Essentially, ChatGPT has turned into that friend who cuts straight to the point and tells you exactly what to do, while Google's still like a helpful librarian giving you multiple recommendations.

The citation game has completely changed 

Here's where it gets interesting (and terrifying). ChatGPT loves mentioning brands but hates linking to them. Only 2 out of 10 brand mentions get an actual link. So your client might be getting mentioned, but they're not getting the traffic.


Perplexity is one extreme of the LLM spectrum and goes full academic mode with over 5 citations per answer, but only mentions brands 1 in 5 times.


Whereas Google AI Overviews tries to split the difference, however, despite impressions being up 49% since AI Overviews launched, click-through rates dropped nearly 30%.

The hardest hit industries 

If you’re selling to digital marketing to local dentists, schools or accountants, you’ll be interested to know they’ve been hit the hardest with search results varying between Google and AI.


  • Healthcare: 62% divergence
  • B2B tech: 47% divergence
  • Education: 45% divergence
  • Finance: 39% divergence (even the "good" news is bad news)


Healthcare got hit hardest with that 62% divergence rate, but why is really matters is because 18.4% of ChatGPT users already use it for health queries. When patients search for specialists, ChatGPT isn't sending them to doctors’ landing pages like Google does. It's giving them straight-up answers and then pushing them straight to Zocdoc, Healthgrades, and insurance directories.


This same pattern is demolishing other industries too. Local accountants are getting bypassed for TurboTax recommendations, and personal trainers are losing out to fitness app suggestions. It’s easy to start hating on AI and thinking it’s anti-local business, but the truth is it’s just pro-efficiency and cutting out the middleman (your clients).

The trick to balancing good SEO and AIO

All that keyword research and content optimisation you're doing is still important, but it's only solving half the problem now. You need to start thinking like two different search engines because that's literally what you're dealing with.


Featured snippets are more likely to trigger AI Overviews, so your traditional SEO game still matters for Google. But ChatGPT doesn't care about your keyword density or meta descriptions. It cares about finding the fastest path from question to action.



Your local restaurant client needs both "Best Italian Food in Downtown" content (for Google's browsing crowd) AND seamless integration with OpenTable, DoorDash, and Uber Eats (for ChatGPT's "just book it" users). One strategy won't cut it anymore.

What to do right now to stay ahead & impress your clients 

1. Audit where your clients actually show up in AI responses. If you're currently using Insites to audit your small-medium business, we have AI readiness checks enabled in the platform. That's your opening - show them their AI invisibility, and suddenly you've got their attention.


If you’ve not yet using Insites, use our free AIO readiness checker on a client to see how they’re showing up in AI like ChatGPT and Gemini (if at all).

Screenshot to show the Insites AIO readiness checker where you get a free audit by entering a URL

2. Get them visible on every relevant third-party platform in their industry. ChatGPT loves pulling from aggregators, so your healthcare clients better have killer profiles on Zocdoc and Healthgrades. Your home service clients need to dominate Checkatrade and HomeAdvisor. This isn't optional anymore.


3. Create content that works for both worlds. Every blog post needs a twin - one for Google's "let me research this" crowd and one for ChatGPT's "just tell me what to do" users. Find ways to maximise your content that speaks to both search models. With subtle tweaks, it won’t take much more effort, and these results are game-changing.


4. Start monitoring AI mentions like your business depends on it (because it does). Brand sentiment can shift overnight in AI responses. The digital marketing providers offering real-time AI dashboards are the ones keeping clients happy and engaged.


5. Position this as business-critical, not experimental. AI search isn't replacing traditional search - it's expanding it. That 49% increase in search impressions? That's a new opportunity, not competition. Frame it right and your clients will see AI optimisation as growth, not protection.

Ready to see where your clients actually rank in AI search? Get a free AI visibility check for any business to see if they're showing up in ChatGPT, AI Overviews, and Gemini.



This is just one of the comprehensive checks included in Insites audits - if you want to know more about getting ahead of this AI search revolution and selling digital marketing at scale, book a call with our team.

decorative
by Izzy Fletcher 24 July 2025
How Google's June Core Update affects digital marketing solution providers who work with small-medium businesses
A woman is giving a high five to another woman.
by Izzy Fletcher 17 July 2025
Understand the difference between SEO and GEO. Need a quick way to audit SMB local business on their SEO and AI ranking? We've got the answer to that too.
A google logo with social media icons surrounding it.
by Izzy Fletcher 10 July 2025
Instagram announced that they will be showing posts from business accounts in Google search results. This is a great opportunity to upsell social media services.
A cartoon of a woman looking through binoculars on a pink background.
by Izzy Fletcher 3 July 2025
Selling digital marketing to local businesses? Discover 5 ways to get them cited in ChatGPT and position your sales team as experts in AI optimisation.
A woman wearing headphones is sitting in front of a laptop computer.
by Izzy Fletcher 24 June 2025
Learn how to handle the 'Is SEO dead?' objection with Google's own data. Turn AI concerns into sales opportunities with proven conversation frameworks.
A man is looking through a magnifying glass at a gear.
by Izzy Fletcher 3 June 2025
Your clients are invisible to ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. Discover 6 critical AI optimisation gaps your sales team should spot to win more deals and future-proof client businesses.
A person is holding a cell phone in their hand surrounded by social media icons.
by Izzy Fletcher 29 May 2025
Surprising data reveals 49% of SMBs are boosting marketing budgets while 75% invest in AI. Get the complete sales playbook for capitalising on these opportunities as a digital marketing provider.
A hand is holding a magnifying glass over a laptop screen that says keyword.
by Coral Wood 28 May 2025
Why keyword research actually matters for small businesses, the challenges digital marketing providers face and how to overcome SEO objections with Insites Keyword Planner.
A magnifying glass over website content
by Coral Wood 21 May 2025
Let's face it - small businesses that have had bad experiences with SEO providers are like someone coming out of a bad relationship. They're wary, skeptical, and probably a bit defensive. And fair enough! Many have shelled out serious cash only to see minimal results, or worse, had their websites damaged by dodgy tactics. These folks aren't just looking for another service provider - they want someone who actually gets their business and can deliver what they promise. Spotting the signs of SEO heartbreak Before you dive into your pitch, take a moment to spot the telltale signs that an SMB has been burned before: They ask super specific questions about your tactics (because they've been bamboozled with jargon before) They want guarantees and exact timelines straight away They're reluctant to share previous work or analytics access They seem suspicious of practices that are actually industry standard They're confused about SEO basics because they've been fed misinformation Remember, this isn't them being difficult—they're just protecting themselves from getting burned again. Show some empathy (and ditch the jargon) When you're chatting with these businesses, the standard sales spiel just won't cut it. Instead: Acknowledge their frustrations without throwing shade at other providers Talk like a normal human being—avoid the technical mumbo-jumbo that might trigger bad memories Be brutally honest about timeframes and what's actually achievable Be crystal clear about how you'll keep them in the loop on progress Show them exactly how you're different from the providers who let them down Building back trust takes time, so don't rush the process. Let the data do the talking Nothing cuts through skepticism like solid data that actually makes sense. Create jargon-free audits that clearly show: What's currently holding their visibility back Opportunities they're missing out on How local competitors are nabbing their potential customers Specific, actionable fixes with realistic outcomes A good audit demonstrates your expertise while giving them immediate value—even before they've paid you a penny. Start small, win big For businesses still nursing their SEO wounds, consider offering: A small starter project with clear deliverables A shorter initial contract without the scary long-term commitment A step-by-step approach with checkpoints before expanding work No sneaky lock-in clauses that got them stuck last time This gives wary clients the chance to see real results before they go all-in. Show your work (properly) Burnt SMBs need extra reassurance that things are actually happening. Create reports that: Show clear before-and-after comparisons Explain technical stuff in plain English Connect improvements to actual business outcomes, not just abstract rankings Are completely honest about what's working and what's not Visual proof of progress works wonders for rebuilding confidence. Teach without the techno-babble Many SMBs have either been kept completely in the dark or bombarded with confusing tech talk. Find the sweet spot by: Creating simple guides tailored to their specific business Using analogies and examples relevant to their industry Breaking complex topics into bite-sized pieces Creating an environment where they feel comfortable asking "stupid" questions A client who understands what you're doing is a client who trusts you. Make it about their business, not just SEO Rather than droning on about algorithms and meta tags, connect your work to what actually matters: Show how SEO improvements translate to more customers Demonstrate the journey from clicks to cash Use examples specific to their industry Show how your work supports their broader business goals This shifts the conversation from "SEO wizardry" to tangible business growth. Real talk: How we helped a skeptical dentist A local dental practice had thrown thousands at SEO with nothing to show for it. When we started working with them, we discovered: Their website had technical errors that were basically making it invisible to Google Despite having a prime high street location, they were nowhere to be seen in local searches Their competitors were actually ranking for their brand name (ouch!) No proper tracking was in place, so previous agencies could hide their lack of results By implementing clear, weekly updates and focusing on quick wins first, we helped them see substantial improvements within three months. Today, they're getting 40% of new patient bookings through their improved online presence. Your action plan for winning over the skeptics Ready to rescue some SEO-burnt businesses? Here's how to start: Create a straightforward audit process that cuts through the confusion Develop simple guides that help business owners understand what you're actually doing Offer flexible contracts that don't feel like a trap Use clear, jargon-free reporting that actually means something Focus on delivering some quick wins to build momentum Remember, winning these clients isn't just about new business—it's about showing them that effective, ethical SEO actually exists! The silver lining of working with the skeptics Here's the thing—SMBs who've had terrible SEO experiences often become your most loyal clients when you finally deliver what others couldn't. By understanding their concerns, being refreshingly transparent, and actually getting results, you're not just winning new business—you're helping repair the reputation of an industry that's let too many small businesses down. More importantly, you're helping local businesses that are the heart of our communities reach the customers they deserve through honest, effective digital marketing. And that's something worth getting out of bed for. Ready to stop guessing which keywords actually matter? Our new Keyword Research tool takes the headache out of SEO planning for your clients. No more cobbling together data from multiple platforms or trying to explain complex metrics to skeptical SMBs. Say goodbye to keyword confusion and hello to: Instant keyword suggestions tailored to your client's industry Easy-to-understand difficulty scores and search volumes Built-in local search insights that show real competitive gaps Simple reporting that actually makes sense to small business owners The best part? It's already included in your Insites subscription at no extra cost. Book a quick demo today to see how our Keyword Research tool can help you win over even the most SEO-traumatised clients with data they can actually understand.
A close-up of a computer screen showing keyword planner on it.
by Coral Wood 15 May 2025
Empower your digital marketing sales team with Insites Keyword Planner. Convert more SMB prospects with instant, AI-powered keyword suggestions that build confidence, save time, and demonstrate clear ROI. No SEO expertise required.
Show More